19:56:45 RRSAgent has joined #wai-wcag 19:56:45 logging to http://www.w3.org/2005/10/27-wai-wcag-irc 19:56:47 RRSAgent, make logs world 19:56:49 WAI_WCAG()4:00PM has now started 19:56:56 +Sofia_Celic 19:56:57 Yvette has joined #wai-wcag 19:57:34 Makoto has joined #wai-wcag 19:57:54 +??P6 19:58:02 Agenda: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/w3c-wai-gl/2005OctDec/0121.html 19:58:13 zakim, ??P6 is Bengt_Farre 19:58:13 +Bengt_Farre; got it 19:58:19 Today I'm a problem with the audio device... i'm only on irc 19:58:32 +Wendy 19:58:47 +[IPcaller] 19:58:50 zakim, [IPcaller] is Makoto_Ueki 19:58:50 +Makoto_Ueki; got it 19:58:52 zakim, I am Bengt_Farre 19:58:52 ok, bengt, I now associate you with Bengt_Farre 19:59:03 +??P8 19:59:09 zakim, mute me 19:59:09 Bengt_Farre should now be muted 19:59:14 zakim, ??P8 is Yvette_Hoitink 19:59:14 +Yvette_Hoitink; got it 19:59:20 zakim, I am Yvette_Hoitink 19:59:20 ok, Yvette, I now associate you with Yvette_Hoitink 19:59:26 +David_MacDonald 19:59:45 Michael has joined #wai-wcag 19:59:57 zakim, mute me 19:59:57 Yvette_Hoitink should now be muted 20:00:23 +Christophe_Strobbe 20:00:29 +??P11 20:00:31 zakim, ??P11 is Gregg_and_Ben 20:00:31 +Gregg_and_Ben; got it 20:00:37 +Alex_Li 20:00:38 rcastaldo has joined #wai-wcag 20:00:45 Hi all 20:00:51 gregg has joined #wai-wcag 20:00:58 sunday for europe 20:01:02 +??P13 20:01:08 regrets: Don Evans, Sandy Bartell 20:01:17 zakim, ??P13 is Katie_Haritos-Shea 20:01:17 +Katie_Haritos-Shea; got it 20:01:33 regrets+ Rob Haverty 20:01:34 + +1.973.482.aaaa - is perhaps Gian_Sampson-Wild? 20:01:56 zakim, +1.973.482.aaaa is Gez_Lemon 20:01:56 sorry, wendy, I do not recognize a party named '+1.973.482.aaaa' 20:02:08 zakim, +1.973 is Gez_Lemon 20:02:08 sorry, wendy, I do not recognize a party named '+1.973' 20:02:09 +Loretta_Guarino_Reid 20:02:11 zakim, who's on the phone? 20:02:11 On the phone I see Sofia_Celic, Bengt_Farre (muted), Wendy, Makoto_Ueki, Yvette_Hoitink (muted), David_MacDonald, Christophe_Strobbe, Gregg_and_Ben, Alex_Li, Katie_Haritos-Shea, 20:02:15 ... Gian_Sampson-Wild?, Loretta_Guarino_Reid 20:02:24 zakim, Gian_Sampson-Wild? is Gez_Lemon 20:02:24 +Gez_Lemon; got it 20:02:24 Becky has joined #wai-wcag 20:02:33 Gez has joined #wai-wcag 20:02:48 +Becky_Gibson 20:03:17 +Michael_Cooper 20:03:25 tryng to connect with dialpad... have some problems 20:04:16 zakim, I am Becky_Gibson 20:04:16 ok, Becky, I now associate you with Becky_Gibson 20:04:21 +??P25 20:04:45 zakim, ??P25 is Lisa_Seeman 20:04:45 +Lisa_Seeman; got it 20:04:51 +??P26 20:05:29 + +1.512.324.aabb 20:05:45 zakim, +1.512.324.aabb is John_Slatin 20:05:45 +John_Slatin; got it 20:05:53 Andi has joined #wai-wcag 20:05:56 zakim, ??P26 is Roberto_Castaldo 20:05:56 +Roberto_Castaldo; got it 20:06:06 +[IBM] 20:06:17 zakim, [IBM] is Andi_Snow-Weaver 20:06:17 +Andi_Snow-Weaver; got it 20:06:28 zakim, who's on the phone? 20:06:28 On the phone I see Sofia_Celic, Bengt_Farre (muted), Wendy, Makoto_Ueki, Yvette_Hoitink (muted), David_MacDonald, Christophe_Strobbe, Gregg_and_Ben, Alex_Li, Katie_Haritos-Shea, 20:06:31 ... Gez_Lemon, Loretta_Guarino_Reid, Becky_Gibson, Michael_Cooper, Lisa_Seeman (muted), Roberto_Castaldo, John_Slatin, Andi_Snow-Weaver 20:07:16 Topic: Status and updates 20:07:31 regrets+ Sebastiano Nutarelli 20:08:54 last week's face-to-face. people worked long hours (~8:30-7:30 each day, with 15 minute breaks and 45 minute lunches) for 4 days. 20:09:39 changes made to wiki. gregg sent two lists of items. The first list - are these ready to go out for the next draft? 20:10:12 The second list - are these changes acceptable? e.g., ok to delete a SC or to combine a couple. 20:10:24 the third list are those things we still need to do - that hasn't been sent yet. 20:12:19 rcast has joined #wai-wcag 20:12:59 +??P29 20:13:15 resolution: first block of items are ready for publication list at: 20:13:44 -Roberto_Castaldo 20:14:04 zakim, ??P29 is Roberto_Castaldo 20:14:04 +Roberto_Castaldo; got it 20:14:06 Topic: Guideline 1.2 L3 SC3 - audio descriptions (live multimedia) 20:14:22 Proposal to delete this success criterion 20:14:24 RATIONALE: because it is almost impossible to do unless the live 20:14:25 multimedia is scripted so you know when people are not talking so you can 20:14:27 speak audio descriptions. In that case we are only talking about live plays 20:14:28 or something and that was not seen as a major enough type of content on the 20:14:30 Web for us to have a success criteria all about it. 20:17:05 zakim, code? 20:17:05 the conference code is 9224 (tel:+1.617.761.6200), wendy 20:17:09 q? 20:18:03 q- 20:18:27 +Matt_May 20:18:31 resolution: delete Guideline 1.2 L3 SC3 - audio descriptions (live multimedia) 20:18:50 +Kerstin_Goldsmith 20:19:11 Topic: Guideline 1.4 L1 SC1 20:19:13 proposal: remove 20:19:14 Rationale: if you conform to other success criteria (1.1 and 1.3) then there are no further requirements. we're assuming that user agents 20:19:16 should or could change color of text and background for contrast as long as the text is programmatically determined. 20:19:24 Topic: Guideline 1.4 L1 SC1 20:19:30 proposal: remove 20:19:31 Rationale: if you conform to other success criteria (1.1 and 1.3) then there are no further requirements. we're assuming that user agents 20:19:33 should or could change color of text and background for contrast as long as the text is programmatically determined. 20:19:57 zakim, mute John_Slatin 20:19:57 John_Slatin should now be muted 20:20:09 zakim, unmute John_Slatin 20:20:09 John_Slatin should no longer be muted 20:20:56 resolution: remove Guideline 1.4 L1 SC1 20:21:06 zakim, mute John_Slatin 20:21:06 John_Slatin should now be muted 20:21:24 Topic: Guideline 3.1 L3 SC1 20:21:29 proposal: delete 20:21:40 Rationale: SC2 covers everything but very common words that are in a standard dictionary. people with cognitive disabilities would be better 20:21:41 off using a dictionary that is tuned for them or that they are at least used to than having each author specifying a different dictionary. it is better for the user to pick the dictionary - something they are used to. 20:21:58 zakim, unmute John_Slatin 20:21:58 John_Slatin was not muted, wendy 20:23:53 concern about disambiuity of words. feeling that it is handled in separate criterion. 20:23:55 ack l 20:24:25 there is a work item about pronunciation (for languages where something else is provided). 20:24:37 that's not the issue was trying to raise. 20:24:49 cites WWAAC work on concept coding. 20:25:54 original idea was about lexicon but evolved to dictionary due to lack of comfort with lexicon. 20:27:21 q+ 20:28:18 ack yv 20:28:18 ack y 20:30:25 discussion if covered by existing level 3 sc 2 (terms used in restricted way) 20:30:32 q+ to say cognitive handicaps require to be able to find the meaning for any word 20:31:02 not disambiguating words, it's concept coding 20:31:11 zakim, mute me 20:31:11 Yvette_Hoitink should now be muted 20:32:42 ack bengt 20:32:44 Bengt_Farre, you wanted to say cognitive handicaps require to be able to find the meaning for any word 20:32:58 mike doesnt work 20:33:00 can't hear you bengt 20:33:06 yep 20:33:36 2 different things conceptcoding sentence and cocneptcode a word 20:33:50 opposing yes 20:34:38 reminder that this SC does not cover concept coding - only that you point to a dictionary. 20:35:03 q+ to say "Concept coding would be allowed here" 20:35:16 yep 20:35:38 lets not forget this point but delete ok 20:35:51 ack joh 20:35:53 ack lor 20:35:55 ack yv 20:35:56 Yvette_Hoitink, you wanted to say "Concept coding would be allowed here" 20:36:16 yep 20:36:42 conceptcoding is pointing to a dictionary that is based a concept 20:38:48 zakim, mute me 20:38:48 Bengt_Farre should now be muted 20:40:25 ack jo 20:40:27 ack lis 20:41:09 q+ 20:42:05 zakim, unmute me 20:42:05 Yvette_Hoitink was not muted, Yvette 20:42:08 ack y 20:43:53 suggestion to keep this as because 1. a "placeholder" for something related to concept coding 2. concern that watering down guidelines wrt cognitive disabilities 20:44:01 need to work on guide document to reflect issues raised today 20:44:37 mcmay has joined #wai-wcag 20:45:05 no consensus. ask for someone to write a proposal and act on at next meeting. 20:45:13 bengt will work on it 20:45:40 action: bengt and lisa proposal for success criterion and guide document by monday to address concept coding. 20:46:12 zakim, loretta has Gian_Sampson-Wild 20:46:12 +Gian_Sampson-Wild; got it 20:46:46 Topic: Guideline 3.2 L3 SC1 20:46:54 proposal to combine with 3.2 L2 SC3 20:47:23 Topic: Guideline 4.2 L2 SC1 20:47:30 proposal to delete 20:47:41 Rationale: moved to a general technique for 4.2 L1 sc6. Also, the implication of the wording is that accessibility conventions would need to be used even if they are not appropriate (e.g., "accesskey"). 20:49:05 resolution: delete Guideline 4.2 L2 SC1 20:49:14 Topic: Guideline 3.2 L3 SC1 20:49:19 proposal to combine with 3.2 L2 SC3 20:51:44 q+ to say "L2 doesn't cover non-functional graphics" 20:52:22 ack jo 20:52:47 clarification - not combine the 2 criteria, but delete the level 3 because it is covered by the level 2 criterion. 20:53:51 and then combine the guide documents since there are good techniques in the l3 guide doc. 20:54:43 ack y 20:54:43 Yvette_Hoitink, you wanted to say "L2 doesn't cover non-functional graphics" 20:54:50 ack yv 21:01:57 this is in guideline 3.2 - about predictable functionality. concern about definition of function. does it include convey information? 21:02:29 q+ to say "if current L3 is already about functional graphics than combine is OK, no matter what functionality really means" 21:02:39 proposal - leave both of them in since what they mean is unclear. someone needs to look at what they say and propose a clarification. 21:03:17 ack yv 21:03:17 Yvette_Hoitink, you wanted to say "if current L3 is already about functional graphics than combine is OK, no matter what functionality really means" 21:03:57 ack li 21:05:36 concern about how this applies to a site that provides a simplified version 21:05:38 ack lor 21:07:30 resolution: combine Guideline 3.2 L3 SC1 and 3.2 L2 SC3 with proviso that we work on using the guide documents to clarify what is covered. 21:07:46 regrets+ Luca_Mascaro 21:08:18 Topic: Guideline 1.3 L3 SC2 21:09:10 ready to go? 21:09:11 http://trace.wisc.edu/wcag_wiki/index.php?title=Guide_to_1.3_L3_SC_2 21:09:25 zakim, mute me 21:09:25 Yvette_Hoitink should now be muted 21:10:12 it's a new SC that hasn't previously been published. 21:11:35 concern that it should be at level 2 21:11:39 +q 21:11:46 q+ 21:11:53 ack kat 21:12:18 ack david 21:12:52 q+ 21:13:48 q+ to discuss ednote Makoto put in 21:13:51 ack mc 21:15:08 proposal, "do not depend solely..." so as not to discourage the practice (similar to practice). don't want to say people can't use, but if they do be redundant with other encoding. 21:15:35 ack li 21:17:30 ack mi 21:17:30 Michael_Cooper, you wanted to discuss ednote Makoto put in 21:18:02 zakim, who's on the phone? 21:18:04 On the phone I see Sofia_Celic, Bengt_Farre (muted), Wendy, Makoto_Ueki, Yvette_Hoitink (muted), David_MacDonald, Christophe_Strobbe, Gregg_and_Ben, Alex_Li, Katie_Haritos-Shea, 21:18:09 ... Gez_Lemon (muted), Loretta_Guarino_Reid, Becky_Gibson, Michael_Cooper, Lisa_Seeman, John_Slatin, Andi_Snow-Weaver, Roberto_Castaldo (muted), Matt_May, Kerstin_Goldsmith 21:18:11 Loretta_Guarino_Reid has Gian_Sampson-Wild 21:20:37 ...in another way that does not depend on shape or location. 21:21:07 When Instructions convey information using visual characteristics such as shape or visual location of components the information is also provided in a way that does not rely on shape or visual location of components. 21:21:18 q+ 21:21:39 q- 21:23:14 When Instructions convey information using visual characteristics such as shape or visual location of components the information is also provided in a way that does not rely on visual characteristics such as shape or visual location of components. 21:24:26 ack lor 21:24:31 ack kat 21:25:24 Instructions for understanding or operating a delivery unit do not depend solely on users' ability to perceive visual characteristics such as shape or visual location of components. 21:25:51 q+ 21:27:11 ack li 21:27:43 concern about tactile markup and other haptic devices that could be used in the future 21:28:16 ack david 21:28:22 q+ christophe 21:28:44 ack chris 21:29:07 proposal: When instructions for understanding or operating a delivery unit use (refer to?) shape or visual location , the instructions do not solely rely on these visual characteristics (i.e. shape and visual location).. 21:29:44 ack john 21:29:46 tactile map link http://tactile.nrcan.gc.ca/page.cgi?url=index_e.html 21:29:59 "user's ability to perceive" is not testable 21:31:04 Instructions for understanding or operating a delivery unit do not depend solely visual characteristics such as shape or visual location of components. 21:31:27 s/solely/solely on 21:32:26 ack kerstin 21:33:21 -Lisa_Seeman 21:33:53 q+ gian 21:34:00 ack lor 21:34:19 if narrow to shape or visual location, should also include size 21:34:25 ack gian 21:34:43 concern that it needs more investigation 21:34:45 I'm sorry, I've got to leave the call now, hear you all next week. Bye all. 21:34:56 -Roberto_Castaldo 21:35:18 Q+ 21:35:30 ack gr 21:36:20 q+ 21:36:42 proposal: instructions do not rely on vision for understanding 21:37:03 q- 21:39:34 ack ker 21:41:15 q+ to say "We did not get back to Makoto (about something still being under consideration)" 21:41:24 ack lor 21:42:10 ack ch 21:42:10 Christophe, you wanted to say "We did not get back to Makoto (about something still being under consideration)" 21:47:15 ack ker 21:48:15 as compared to JIS: our current wording limits to instructions but is broader (to all visual characteristics) 21:49:11 q+ 21:50:17 action: kerstin and makoto work on rewording of SC of about "shape and locaiton" and guide doc. 21:51:24 ack andi 21:52:03 ack lor 21:52:46 ack ker 21:53:14 ack john 21:54:22 Information required to understand and operate Web content does not rely on shape and location alone. 21:54:59 Information required to understand and operate Web content shall not rely on shape or location alone. 21:55:26 resolution: adopt at level 2 with guide doc on the way from kerstin and makoto - Information required to understand and operate Web content does not rely on shape or location alone. 21:55:43 ack kat 21:57:39 action: katie "next round we should..." wrt Guideline 1.3 L3 SC2 21:58:32 RRSAgent, drop action 3 21:58:36 zakim, who's making noise? 21:58:46 wendy, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: Makoto_Ueki (30%) 21:59:00 zakim, mute me 21:59:00 Makoto_Ueki should now be muted 21:59:49 Topic: guides that need work and who's working on them 22:00:13 Topic: things for next week 22:00:26 -Christophe_Strobbe 22:00:35 guideline 1.2 l1 sc1 captions - level 1 or 2? 22:00:46 guideline 1.2 l1 sc 2 audio descriptions - level 1 or 2 22:01:18 guideline 3.1 L3 SC2, SC3, and SC5 - move from level 3 to level 2? 22:01:30 we will send surveys on these items. 22:02:03 s/surveys/survey 22:02:16 Topic: guides that need work and who's working on them 22:02:18 zakim, who's making noise? 22:02:30 wendy, listening for 10 seconds I heard sound from the following: Kerstin_Goldsmith (28%), Gregg_and_Ben (66%), Loretta_Guarino_Reid (13%), John_Slatin (29%) 22:02:46 zakim, mute Kerstin 22:02:46 Kerstin_Goldsmith should now be muted 22:04:27 latest notes. rough. 22:04:29 * Guideline 1.3 L1 SC1 - Wendy, Loretta, Andi, David 22:04:30 * Guideline 1.3 L1 SC2 - Gregg 22:04:32 * Guideline 1.3 L2 SC1 - Gregg 22:04:34 * Guideline 1.3 L2 SC2 - ?? needs work ?? 22:04:35 * Guideline 1.3 L3 SC1 - Loretta 22:04:36 * Guideline 1.4 L2 SC1 - Gregg. Add numbers for the algorithm then survey for review. 22:04:38 * Guideline 1.4 L3 SC1 - Gregg. Add numbers. 22:04:39 * Guideline 2.1 L1 SC1 - Gregg. New wording means changes needed to intent and perhaps addition of a couple notes. 22:04:41 * Guideline 2.2 L1 SC1 - Michael, Andi, Don (and maybe Alex) discuss server time-outs. Loretta and Gian to consider how to handle auction example. Several editorial changes needed related to intent section (adopt proposals from John, Gregg, and Andi) 22:04:43 * Guideline 2.2 L3 SC3 - Becky ask security expert about techniques. Becky and David ask for clarification from Roberto Scano about his comment in the survey (about IIS). 22:04:44 * Guideline 2.3 - Gregg 22:04:46 * Guideline 2.4 L1 SC1 - Andi, Wendy, Loretta, David (in conjunction with G1.3 L1 SC1) 22:04:48 * Guideline 2.4 L2 SC1 - Wendy, Becky, Alex 22:04:50 * Guideline 2.4 L3 SC4 - ?? there is alterantive wording of the SC but not clear that we agreed on it. Is someone supposed to work on proposal for new wording or adopt what's there? 22:04:53 * Guideline 4.2 L1 SC2 - waiting for editorial as well as 2.3 resolutions? 22:04:55 * Guideline 4.2 L1 SC5 - Gregg and Gez to write definitions. 22:04:57 * Guideline 4.2 L1 SC6 - lots of notes. needs cleaned up. 22:06:01 -Andi_Snow-Weaver 22:07:37 http://trace.wisc.edu/wcag_wiki/index.php?title=Proposed_Guide_to_2.4_L2_SC4 22:08:59 guideline 2.4 L2 SC4 - decided to wait for discussion. think it's ready to discuss. 22:09:35 survey both wordings in survey 22:09:37 ack kat 22:11:05 Guideline 4.2 L1 SC6 http://trace.wisc.edu/wcag_wiki/index.php?title=Guide_to_4.2_L1_SC_6 22:11:32 michael sent email to list 22:12:02 michael to work on 4.2 L1 SC6 22:13:27 zakim, unmute me 22:13:27 Yvette_Hoitink should no longer be muted 22:15:43 instead of "guide" call "intent and best practice" 22:15:48 what about "explation and examples" 22:17:06 -Katie_Haritos-Shea 22:17:07 -Alex_Li 22:17:08 -Wendy 22:17:08 gnight 22:17:09 -Sofia_Celic 22:17:10 -Kerstin_Goldsmith 22:17:11 -Loretta_Guarino_Reid 22:17:12 -Matt_May 22:17:14 -Gregg_and_Ben 22:17:15 -John_Slatin 22:17:15 wave 22:17:16 -Michael_Cooper 22:17:18 -Yvette_Hoitink 22:17:19 -Becky_Gibson 22:17:21 -David_MacDonald 22:17:23 -Bengt_Farre 22:17:25 -Gez_Lemon 22:17:27 WAI_WCAG()4:00PM has ended 22:17:29 Attendees were Sofia_Celic, Bengt_Farre, Wendy, Makoto_Ueki, Yvette_Hoitink, David_MacDonald, Christophe_Strobbe, Gregg_and_Ben, Alex_Li, Katie_Haritos-Shea, +1.973.482.aaaa, 22:17:32 ... Gez_Lemon, Becky_Gibson, Michael_Cooper, Lisa_Seeman, John_Slatin, Roberto_Castaldo, Andi_Snow-Weaver, Matt_May, Kerstin_Goldsmith, Gian_Sampson-Wild 22:17:51 RRSAgent, generate minutes 22:17:51 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2005/10/27-wai-wcag-minutes.html wendy 22:18:03 ben has left #wai-wcag 22:18:03 bengt has left #wai-wcag 22:19:49 Makoto has left #wai-wcag 22:26:56 Christophe has left #wai-wcag 22:41:29 Meeting: WCAG WG weekly telecon 22:41:36 chair: Gregg 22:41:50 RRSAgent, generate minutes 22:41:50 I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2005/10/27-wai-wcag-minutes.html wendy 22:42:02 zakim, bye 22:42:02 Zakim has left #wai-wcag 22:55:12 RRSAgent, bye 22:55:12 I see 2 open action items saved in http://www.w3.org/2005/10/27-wai-wcag-actions.rdf : 22:55:12 ACTION: bengt and lisa proposal for success criterion and guide document by monday to address concept coding. [1] 22:55:12 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2005/10/27-wai-wcag-irc#T20-45-40 22:55:12 ACTION: kerstin and makoto work on rewording of SC of about "shape and locaiton" and guide doc. [2] 22:55:12 recorded in http://www.w3.org/2005/10/27-wai-wcag-irc#T21-50-17