RDF Core Test Results

Primary version lives at http://www.w3.org/2003/11/results/rdf-core-tests

See the announcement of this page, and the similar OWL Test Results.

Contents

  1. Results Grouped By Test Type
  2. Results Grouped By Number of Passes
  3. Results Grouped By Number Of Fails

Results Grouped By Test Type

Approved
Positive Parser Test128
Negative Parser Test41
Positive Entailment Test21
Negative Entailment Test21
Miscellaneous Test1

Positive Parser Test (128 Approved)

Testrdflib: RDF Library for PythonRDF API for PHP V0.7RDFStore RDF/XML ParserRaptor RDF Parser3store RDF engineJena2Euler
Percent Passing (of 128 tests)98%96%79%100%11%100%75%
amp-in-url-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
datatypes-test001 [APPROVED] A simple datatype production; a language+datatype production. Simply duplicate the constructs under http://www.w3.org/2000/10/rdf-tests/rdfcore/ntriples/test.nt FailPassPassPassPassPassPass
datatypes-test002 [APPROVED] A parser is not required to know about well-formed datatyped literals. PassPassPassPassPassPassUndecided
rdf-charmod-literals-test001 [APPROVED] Does the treatment of literals conform to charmod ? Test for success of legal Normal Form C literal PassFailPassPassPassPassUndecided
rdf-charmod-uris-test001 [APPROVED] A uriref is allowed to match non-US ASCII forms conforming to Unicode Normal Form C. No escaping algorithm is applied. PassFailPassPassPassPassUndecided
rdf-charmod-uris-test002 [APPROVED] A uriref which already has % escaping is permitted. No unescaping algorithm is applied. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test007 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test008 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
rdf-element-not-mandatory-test001 [APPROVED] A surrounding rdf:RDF element is no longer mandatory. PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0009 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0010 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0011 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0012 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0013 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0014 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-difference-between-ID-and-about-test1 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-difference-between-ID-and-about-test2 [APPROVED] This test shows the treatment of non-ASCII characters in the value of rdf:ID attribute. PassFailFailPassPassPassUndecided
rdfms-difference-between-ID-and-about-test3 [APPROVED] This test shows the treatment of non-ASCII characters in the value of rdf:about attribute. PassFailFailPassPassPassUndecided
rdfms-duplicate-member-props-test001 [APPROVED] The question posed to the RDF WG was: should an RDF document containing multiple rdf:_n properties (with the same n) on an element be rejected as illegal? The WG decided that a parser should accept that case as legal RDF. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test007 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test008 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test009 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test010 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test011 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test012 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test013 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test014 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test015 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test016 [APPROVED] Like rdfms-empty-property-elements/test001.rdf but with a processing instruction as the only content of the otherwise empty element. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test017 [APPROVED] Like rdfms-empty-property-elements/test001.rdf but with a comment as the only content of the otherwise empty element. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdfms-identity-anon-resources-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-identity-anon-resources-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-identity-anon-resources-test003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-identity-anon-resources-test004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-identity-anon-resources-test005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-not-id-and-resource-attr-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-not-id-and-resource-attr-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-not-id-and-resource-attr-test004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-not-id-and-resource-attr-test005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-para196-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-007 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-008 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-009 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-010 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-011 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-012 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-013 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-014 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-015 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-016 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-017 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-018 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-019 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-020 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-021 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-022 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-023 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-024 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-025 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-026 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-027 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-028 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-029 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-030 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-031 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-032 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-033 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-034 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-035 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-036 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-037 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-warn-001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-warn-002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-warn-003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-reification-required-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-seq-representation-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)FailPassFailPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-test001 [APPROVED] rdf:nodeID can be used to label a blank node. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-test002 [APPROVED] rdf:nodeID can be used to label a blank node. These have file scope and are distinct from any unlabelled blank nodes. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-test003 [APPROVED] On an rdf:Description or typed node rdf:nodeID behaves similarly to an rdf:about. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-test004 [APPROVED] On a property element rdf:nodeID behaves similarly to rdf:resource. PassPassUndecidedPassPassPassUndecided
rdfms-uri-substructure-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xml-literal-namespaces-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-xml-literal-namespaces-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-xmllang-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xmllang-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xmllang-test003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xmllang-test004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xmllang-test005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xmllang-test006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfs-domain-and-range-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfs-domain-and-range-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
unrecognised-xml-attributes-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
unrecognised-xml-attributes-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
xml-canon-test001 [APPROVED] Demonstrating the canonicalisation of XMLLiterals. PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
xmlbase-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
xmlbase-test006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
xmlbase-test007 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test008 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test009 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test010 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test011 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test013 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
xmlbase-test014 [APPROVED] Test output corrected to use correct base URL. PassPassPassPassPassPassUndecided

Negative Parser Test (41 Approved)

Testrdflib: RDF Library for PythonRDF API for PHP V0.7RDFStore RDF/XML ParserRaptor RDF ParserJena2
Percent Passing (of 41 tests)100%97% 0%100%100%
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-error001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-error002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-abouteach-error001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassPass
rdfms-abouteach-error002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-difference-between-ID-and-about-error1 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassFailFailPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-error001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-error002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-error003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error001 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:ID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error002 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:ID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error003 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:ID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error004 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:ID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error005 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:ID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error006 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:bagID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error007 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:bagID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-007 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-008 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-009 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-010 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-011 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-012 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-013 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-014 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-015 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-016 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-017 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-018 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-019 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-020 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-error001 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:nodeID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-error002 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:nodeID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-error003 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:nodeID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-error004 [APPROVED] Cannot have rdf:nodeID and rdf:ID. PassPassUndecidedPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-error005 [APPROVED] Cannot have rdf:nodeID and rdf:about. PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-error006 [APPROVED] Cannot have rdf:nodeID and rdf:resource. PassPassFailPassPass

Positive Entailment Test (21 Approved)

Test3store RDF engineJena2EulerSurnia
Percent Passing (of 21 tests)57%71%100%47%
datatypes-intensional-xsd-integer-string-incompatible [APPROVED] The claim that xsd:integer is a subClassOF xsd:string is incompatible with using the intensional semantics for datatypes. no dataPassPassno data
datatypes-non-well-formed-literal-1 [APPROVED] Without datatype knowledge, a 'badly-formed' datatyped literal cannot be detected. PassPassPassPass
datatypes-plain-literal-and-xsd-string [APPROVED] A plain literal denotes the same thing as its corresponding xsd:string, where one exists. no dataPassPassno data
datatypes-range-clash [APPROVED] Where sufficient DT knowledge is available, a range clash may be detected; the document then contains a contradiction. PassPassPassno data
datatypes-semantic-equivalence-between-datatypes [APPROVED] Members of different datatypes may be semantically equivalent. FailPassPassno data
datatypes-semantic-equivalence-within-type-1 [APPROVED] Demonstrating the semantic equivalence of two lexical forms of the same datatyped value. PassPassPassno data
datatypes-semantic-equivalence-within-type-2 [APPROVED] As semantic-equivalence-within-type-1; the entailment works both ways. PassPassPassno data
datatypes-test008 [APPROVED] From decisions listed in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/w3c-rdfcore-wg/2002Oct/0098.html PassPassPassno data
datatypes-test010 [APPROVED] From decisions listed in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/w3c-rdfcore-wg/2002Oct/0098.html PassPassPassno data
pfps-10-non-well-formed-literal-1 [APPROVED] Test that ICEXT(I(rdfs:Literal)) is a subset of LV. no datano dataPassPass
rdfms-seq-representation-test002 [APPROVED] Statement of the MT closure rule. FailFailPassPass
rdfms-seq-representation-test003 [APPROVED] Statement of the MT closure rule. PassPassPassPass
rdfms-seq-representation-test004 [APPROVED] Statement of the MT closure rule. FailFailPassPass
rdfs-entailment-test001 [APPROVED] Indicating a simple inconsistency drawn from RDFS. RDFS can only produce inconsistencies through badly-formed XMLLiteral datatypes. no datano dataPassno data
rdfs-entailment-test002 [APPROVED] From an inconsistent graph, any entailment can be drawn. This is an example. no datano dataPassno data
rdfs-no-cycles-in-subClassOf-test001 [APPROVED] Cycles are permitted in subClassOf; therefore, no error occurs and the following entailment holds trivially. PassPassPassPass
rdfs-no-cycles-in-subPropertyOf-test001 [APPROVED] Cycles are permitted in subPropertyOf; therefore, no error occurs and the following entailment holds trivially. PassPassPassPass
rdfs-subPropertyOf-semantics-test001 [APPROVED] The inheritance semantics of the subPropertyOf relationship needs to be clarified. => subProperties inherit conjunctively the domain and range of their superproperties PassPassPassPass
tex-01-language-tag-case-1 [APPROVED] The case of the language tag is not significant. PassPassPassPass
tex-01-language-tag-case-2 [APPROVED] The case of the language tag is not significant. PassPassPassPass
xmlsch-02-whitespace-facet-3 [APPROVED] A simple test for well-formedness of a typed literal. Failno dataPassno data

Negative Entailment Test (21 Approved)

Negative Entailment Tests are expected here to be used mostly as an extra check for systems built to determine positive entailments. Under normal circumstances, these systems will produce "Undecided" for these tests; only a "Fail" is a sign of a problem.

To actually pass a Negative Entailment Test, a reasoner must be complete with respect to the semantics (eg RDFS) and datatype theories (eg xsd:int, XMLLiteral) associated with the test. Since no serious use-cases have emerged for such a system, it is unknown whether they will ever cost-effective to build. Their absence should not be construed as lack of implementation of RDF systems.

Test3store RDF engineJena2EulerSurnia
Percent Passing (of 21 tests)76% 0% 0%57%
datatypes-intensional-xsd-integer-decimal-compatible [APPROVED] The claim that xsd:integer is a subClassOF xsd:decimal is not incompatible with using the intensional semantics for datatypes. no dataUndecidedUndecidedno data
datatypes-non-well-formed-literal-2 [APPROVED] With appropriate datatype knowledge, a 'badly-formed' datatyped literal can be detected. PassUndecidedUndecidedno data
datatypes-test009 [APPROVED] From decisions listed in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/w3c-rdfcore-wg/2002Oct/0098.html FailUndecidedUndecidedno data
horst-01-subClassOf-intensional [APPROVED] rdfs:subClassOf has intensional semantics, not extensional. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
horst-01-subPropertyOf-intensional [APPROVED] rdfs:subPropertyOf has intensional semantics, not extensional. PassUndecidedFailPass
rdf-charmod-uris-test003 [APPROVED] An international URI ref and its %-escaped form label different nodes in the graph. No model theoretic relationship holds between them. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
rdf-charmod-uris-test004 [APPROVED] An international URI ref and its %-escaped form label different nodes in the graph. No model theoretic relationship holds between them. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
rdfms-xmllang-test007a [APPROVED] Plain literals are distinguishable on the basis of language tags. no dataUndecidedUndecidedno data
rdfms-xmllang-test007b [APPROVED] Plain literals are distinguishable on the basis of language tags. no dataUndecidedUndecidedno data
rdfms-xmllang-test007c [APPROVED] Plain literals are distinguishable on the basis of language tags. no dataUndecidedUndecidedno data
rdfs-container-membership-superProperty-test001 [APPROVED] While it is a superproperty, _:a <rdfs:contains (@@member?)> _:b . does NOT entail _:a <rdf:_n> _:b . for any _n. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
rdfs-domain-and-range-intensionality-domain [APPROVED] RDF Semantics defines rdfs:range to have an intensional reading of domain. However, semantic extensions may give an extensional reading to domain. The premise/conclusion pair is a non-entailment for RDFS reasoning, but may hold in semantic extensions. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
rdfs-domain-and-range-intensionality-range [APPROVED] RDF Semantics defines rdfs:range to have an intensional reading. However, semantic extensions may give an extensional reading to range. The premise/conclusion pair is a non-entailment for RDFS reasoning, but may hold in semantic extensions. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
rdfs-subClassOf-a-Property-test001 [APPROVED] an instance of the Property class may have an rdfs:subClassOf property. the meaning of such a property is defined by the model theory. The wording of the formal resolution is a bit bare, so let me add a few words of explanation. What this means is that a resource can be both a class and a property. This test is encoded as follows: a Property may have a subclass (that is, such an RDF graph is satisfiable) PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
statement-entailment-test001 [APPROVED] RDFCore WG RESOLVED that a reified statement was a stating, not a statement. The following entailment does not, therefore, hold. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
statement-entailment-test002 [APPROVED] RDFCore WG RESOLVED that a statement does NOT entail its reification. The following entailment does not, therefore, hold. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
statement-entailment-test003 [APPROVED] RDFCore WG RESOLVED that a reified statement was a stating, not a statement. The following entailment does not, therefore, hold. This is the same as test001, but using RDFS-entailment. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
statement-entailment-test004 [APPROVED] RDFCore WG RESOLVED that a statement does NOT entail its reification. The following entailment does not, therefore, hold. This is the same as test002, but using RDFS-entailment. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
xmlsch-02-whitespace-facet-1 [APPROVED] A well-formed typed literal is not related to an ill-formed literal. Even if they only differ by whitespace. PassUndecidedFailno data
xmlsch-02-whitespace-facet-2 [APPROVED] A well-formed typed literal is not related to an ill-formed literal. Even if they only differ by whitespace. PassUndecidedFailno data
xmlsch-02-whitespace-facet-4 [APPROVED] An integer with whitespace is ill-formed. PassUndecidedFailno data

Miscellaneous Test (1 Approved)

Test
Percent Passing (of 1 tests)
rdfms-uri-substructure-error001 [APPROVED] An RDF/XML serlializer is recommended to produce an exception if asked to serialize the following graph since there is no way to represent it in the RDF/XML syntax.

Results Grouped By Number of Passes

Approved
Positive Parser TestNegative Parser TestPositive Entailment TestNegative Entailment TestMiscellaneous Test
Tests With 0 Passes00051
Tests With 1 Pass00340
Tests With 2 Passes006120
Tests With 3 Passes01500
Tests With 4 Passes1140700
Tests With 5 Passes330000
Tests With 6 Passes770000
Tests With 7 Passes70000

Tests With 0 Passes (5 Approved Negative Entailment Test)

Negative Entailment Tests are expected here to be used mostly as an extra check for systems built to determine positive entailments. Under normal circumstances, these systems will produce "Undecided" for these tests; only a "Fail" is a sign of a problem.

To actually pass a Negative Entailment Test, a reasoner must be complete with respect to the semantics (eg RDFS) and datatype theories (eg xsd:int, XMLLiteral) associated with the test. Since no serious use-cases have emerged for such a system, it is unknown whether they will ever cost-effective to build. Their absence should not be construed as lack of implementation of RDF systems.

Test3store RDF engineJena2Euler
Percent Passing (of 5 tests) 0% 0% 0%
datatypes-intensional-xsd-integer-decimal-compatible [APPROVED] The claim that xsd:integer is a subClassOF xsd:decimal is not incompatible with using the intensional semantics for datatypes. no dataUndecidedUndecided
datatypes-test009 [APPROVED] From decisions listed in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/w3c-rdfcore-wg/2002Oct/0098.html FailUndecidedUndecided
rdfms-xmllang-test007a [APPROVED] Plain literals are distinguishable on the basis of language tags. no dataUndecidedUndecided
rdfms-xmllang-test007b [APPROVED] Plain literals are distinguishable on the basis of language tags. no dataUndecidedUndecided
rdfms-xmllang-test007c [APPROVED] Plain literals are distinguishable on the basis of language tags. no dataUndecidedUndecided

Tests With 0 Passes (1 Approved Miscellaneous Test)

Test
Percent Passing (of 1 tests)
rdfms-uri-substructure-error001 [APPROVED] An RDF/XML serlializer is recommended to produce an exception if asked to serialize the following graph since there is no way to represent it in the RDF/XML syntax.

Tests With 1 Pass (3 Approved Positive Entailment Test)

Test3store RDF engineEuler
Percent Passing (of 3 tests) 0%100%
rdfs-entailment-test001 [APPROVED] Indicating a simple inconsistency drawn from RDFS. RDFS can only produce inconsistencies through badly-formed XMLLiteral datatypes. no dataPass
rdfs-entailment-test002 [APPROVED] From an inconsistent graph, any entailment can be drawn. This is an example. no dataPass
xmlsch-02-whitespace-facet-3 [APPROVED] A simple test for well-formedness of a typed literal. FailPass

Tests With 1 Pass (4 Approved Negative Entailment Test)

Negative Entailment Tests are expected here to be used mostly as an extra check for systems built to determine positive entailments. Under normal circumstances, these systems will produce "Undecided" for these tests; only a "Fail" is a sign of a problem.

To actually pass a Negative Entailment Test, a reasoner must be complete with respect to the semantics (eg RDFS) and datatype theories (eg xsd:int, XMLLiteral) associated with the test. Since no serious use-cases have emerged for such a system, it is unknown whether they will ever cost-effective to build. Their absence should not be construed as lack of implementation of RDF systems.

Test3store RDF engineJena2Euler
Percent Passing (of 4 tests)100% 0% 0%
datatypes-non-well-formed-literal-2 [APPROVED] With appropriate datatype knowledge, a 'badly-formed' datatyped literal can be detected. PassUndecidedUndecided
xmlsch-02-whitespace-facet-1 [APPROVED] A well-formed typed literal is not related to an ill-formed literal. Even if they only differ by whitespace. PassUndecidedFail
xmlsch-02-whitespace-facet-2 [APPROVED] A well-formed typed literal is not related to an ill-formed literal. Even if they only differ by whitespace. PassUndecidedFail
xmlsch-02-whitespace-facet-4 [APPROVED] An integer with whitespace is ill-formed. PassUndecidedFail

Tests With 2 Passes (6 Approved Positive Entailment Test)

Test3store RDF engineJena2EulerSurnia
Percent Passing (of 6 tests) 0%50%100%50%
datatypes-intensional-xsd-integer-string-incompatible [APPROVED] The claim that xsd:integer is a subClassOF xsd:string is incompatible with using the intensional semantics for datatypes. no dataPassPassno data
datatypes-plain-literal-and-xsd-string [APPROVED] A plain literal denotes the same thing as its corresponding xsd:string, where one exists. no dataPassPassno data
datatypes-semantic-equivalence-between-datatypes [APPROVED] Members of different datatypes may be semantically equivalent. FailPassPassno data
pfps-10-non-well-formed-literal-1 [APPROVED] Test that ICEXT(I(rdfs:Literal)) is a subset of LV. no datano dataPassPass
rdfms-seq-representation-test002 [APPROVED] Statement of the MT closure rule. FailFailPassPass
rdfms-seq-representation-test004 [APPROVED] Statement of the MT closure rule. FailFailPassPass

Tests With 2 Passes (12 Approved Negative Entailment Test)

Negative Entailment Tests are expected here to be used mostly as an extra check for systems built to determine positive entailments. Under normal circumstances, these systems will produce "Undecided" for these tests; only a "Fail" is a sign of a problem.

To actually pass a Negative Entailment Test, a reasoner must be complete with respect to the semantics (eg RDFS) and datatype theories (eg xsd:int, XMLLiteral) associated with the test. Since no serious use-cases have emerged for such a system, it is unknown whether they will ever cost-effective to build. Their absence should not be construed as lack of implementation of RDF systems.

Test3store RDF engineJena2EulerSurnia
Percent Passing (of 12 tests)100% 0% 0%100%
horst-01-subClassOf-intensional [APPROVED] rdfs:subClassOf has intensional semantics, not extensional. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
horst-01-subPropertyOf-intensional [APPROVED] rdfs:subPropertyOf has intensional semantics, not extensional. PassUndecidedFailPass
rdf-charmod-uris-test003 [APPROVED] An international URI ref and its %-escaped form label different nodes in the graph. No model theoretic relationship holds between them. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
rdf-charmod-uris-test004 [APPROVED] An international URI ref and its %-escaped form label different nodes in the graph. No model theoretic relationship holds between them. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
rdfs-container-membership-superProperty-test001 [APPROVED] While it is a superproperty, _:a <rdfs:contains (@@member?)> _:b . does NOT entail _:a <rdf:_n> _:b . for any _n. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
rdfs-domain-and-range-intensionality-domain [APPROVED] RDF Semantics defines rdfs:range to have an intensional reading of domain. However, semantic extensions may give an extensional reading to domain. The premise/conclusion pair is a non-entailment for RDFS reasoning, but may hold in semantic extensions. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
rdfs-domain-and-range-intensionality-range [APPROVED] RDF Semantics defines rdfs:range to have an intensional reading. However, semantic extensions may give an extensional reading to range. The premise/conclusion pair is a non-entailment for RDFS reasoning, but may hold in semantic extensions. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
rdfs-subClassOf-a-Property-test001 [APPROVED] an instance of the Property class may have an rdfs:subClassOf property. the meaning of such a property is defined by the model theory. The wording of the formal resolution is a bit bare, so let me add a few words of explanation. What this means is that a resource can be both a class and a property. This test is encoded as follows: a Property may have a subclass (that is, such an RDF graph is satisfiable) PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
statement-entailment-test001 [APPROVED] RDFCore WG RESOLVED that a reified statement was a stating, not a statement. The following entailment does not, therefore, hold. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
statement-entailment-test002 [APPROVED] RDFCore WG RESOLVED that a statement does NOT entail its reification. The following entailment does not, therefore, hold. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
statement-entailment-test003 [APPROVED] RDFCore WG RESOLVED that a reified statement was a stating, not a statement. The following entailment does not, therefore, hold. This is the same as test001, but using RDFS-entailment. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
statement-entailment-test004 [APPROVED] RDFCore WG RESOLVED that a statement does NOT entail its reification. The following entailment does not, therefore, hold. This is the same as test002, but using RDFS-entailment. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass

Tests With 3 Passes (1 Approved Negative Parser Test)

Testrdflib: RDF Library for PythonRDF API for PHP V0.7RDFStore RDF/XML ParserRaptor RDF ParserJena2
Percent Passing (of 1 tests)100% 0% 0%100%100%
rdfms-difference-between-ID-and-about-error1 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassFailFailPassPass

Tests With 3 Passes (5 Approved Positive Entailment Test)

Test3store RDF engineJena2Euler
Percent Passing (of 5 tests)100%100%100%
datatypes-range-clash [APPROVED] Where sufficient DT knowledge is available, a range clash may be detected; the document then contains a contradiction. PassPassPass
datatypes-semantic-equivalence-within-type-1 [APPROVED] Demonstrating the semantic equivalence of two lexical forms of the same datatyped value. PassPassPass
datatypes-semantic-equivalence-within-type-2 [APPROVED] As semantic-equivalence-within-type-1; the entailment works both ways. PassPassPass
datatypes-test008 [APPROVED] From decisions listed in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/w3c-rdfcore-wg/2002Oct/0098.html PassPassPass
datatypes-test010 [APPROVED] From decisions listed in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/w3c-rdfcore-wg/2002Oct/0098.html PassPassPass

Tests With 4 Passes (11 Approved Positive Parser Test)

Testrdflib: RDF Library for PythonRDF API for PHP V0.7RDFStore RDF/XML ParserRaptor RDF Parser3store RDF engineJena2Euler
Percent Passing (of 11 tests)90%81% 0%100%18%100% 9%
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
rdf-element-not-mandatory-test001 [APPROVED] A surrounding rdf:RDF element is no longer mandatory. PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-difference-between-ID-and-about-test2 [APPROVED] This test shows the treatment of non-ASCII characters in the value of rdf:ID attribute. PassFailFailPassPassPassUndecided
rdfms-difference-between-ID-and-about-test3 [APPROVED] This test shows the treatment of non-ASCII characters in the value of rdf:about attribute. PassFailFailPassPassPassUndecided
rdfms-not-id-and-resource-attr-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-not-id-and-resource-attr-test004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-not-id-and-resource-attr-test005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-seq-representation-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)FailPassFailPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xml-literal-namespaces-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-xml-literal-namespaces-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
xmlbase-test013 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided

Tests With 4 Passes (40 Approved Negative Parser Test)

Testrdflib: RDF Library for PythonRDF API for PHP V0.7RDFStore RDF/XML ParserRaptor RDF ParserJena2
Percent Passing (of 40 tests)100%100% 0%100%100%
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-error001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-error002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-abouteach-error001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassPass
rdfms-abouteach-error002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-error001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-error002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-error003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error001 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:ID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error002 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:ID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error003 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:ID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error004 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:ID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error005 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:ID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error006 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:bagID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error007 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:bagID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-007 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-008 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-009 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-010 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-011 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-012 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-013 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-014 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-015 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-016 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-017 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-018 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-019 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-020 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-error001 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:nodeID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-error002 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:nodeID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-error003 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:nodeID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-error004 [APPROVED] Cannot have rdf:nodeID and rdf:ID. PassPassUndecidedPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-error005 [APPROVED] Cannot have rdf:nodeID and rdf:about. PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-error006 [APPROVED] Cannot have rdf:nodeID and rdf:resource. PassPassFailPassPass

Tests With 4 Passes (7 Approved Positive Entailment Test)

Test3store RDF engineJena2EulerSurnia
Percent Passing (of 7 tests)100%100%100%100%
datatypes-non-well-formed-literal-1 [APPROVED] Without datatype knowledge, a 'badly-formed' datatyped literal cannot be detected. PassPassPassPass
rdfms-seq-representation-test003 [APPROVED] Statement of the MT closure rule. PassPassPassPass
rdfs-no-cycles-in-subClassOf-test001 [APPROVED] Cycles are permitted in subClassOf; therefore, no error occurs and the following entailment holds trivially. PassPassPassPass
rdfs-no-cycles-in-subPropertyOf-test001 [APPROVED] Cycles are permitted in subPropertyOf; therefore, no error occurs and the following entailment holds trivially. PassPassPassPass
rdfs-subPropertyOf-semantics-test001 [APPROVED] The inheritance semantics of the subPropertyOf relationship needs to be clarified. => subProperties inherit conjunctively the domain and range of their superproperties PassPassPassPass
tex-01-language-tag-case-1 [APPROVED] The case of the language tag is not significant. PassPassPassPass
tex-01-language-tag-case-2 [APPROVED] The case of the language tag is not significant. PassPassPassPass

Tests With 5 Passes (33 Approved Positive Parser Test)

Testrdflib: RDF Library for PythonRDF API for PHP V0.7RDFStore RDF/XML ParserRaptor RDF Parser3store RDF engineJena2Euler
Percent Passing (of 33 tests)100%93%54%100% 9%100%42%
rdf-charmod-literals-test001 [APPROVED] Does the treatment of literals conform to charmod ? Test for success of legal Normal Form C literal PassFailPassPassPassPassUndecided
rdf-charmod-uris-test001 [APPROVED] A uriref is allowed to match non-US ASCII forms conforming to Unicode Normal Form C. No escaping algorithm is applied. PassFailPassPassPassPassUndecided
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test007 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test008 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0011 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0012 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0013 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0014 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-difference-between-ID-and-about-test1 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test011 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test012 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-not-id-and-resource-attr-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-017 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-018 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-019 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-031 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-032 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-033 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-034 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-test004 [APPROVED] On a property element rdf:nodeID behaves similarly to rdf:resource. PassPassUndecidedPassPassPassUndecided
unrecognised-xml-attributes-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
xml-canon-test001 [APPROVED] Demonstrating the canonicalisation of XMLLiterals. PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
xmlbase-test004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
xmlbase-test006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
xmlbase-test008 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test011 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass

Tests With 6 Passes (77 Approved Positive Parser Test)

Testrdflib: RDF Library for PythonRDF API for PHP V0.7RDFStore RDF/XML ParserRaptor RDF Parser3store RDF engineJena2Euler
Percent Passing (of 77 tests)98%100%100%100% 3%100%97%
amp-in-url-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
datatypes-test001 [APPROVED] A simple datatype production; a language+datatype production. Simply duplicate the constructs under http://www.w3.org/2000/10/rdf-tests/rdfcore/ntriples/test.nt FailPassPassPassPassPassPass
datatypes-test002 [APPROVED] A parser is not required to know about well-formed datatyped literals. PassPassPassPassPassPassUndecided
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0009 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0010 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test007 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test008 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test009 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test010 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test013 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test014 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test015 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-identity-anon-resources-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-identity-anon-resources-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-identity-anon-resources-test003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-identity-anon-resources-test004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-identity-anon-resources-test005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-para196-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-007 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-008 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-009 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-010 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-011 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-012 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-013 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-014 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-015 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-016 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-020 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-021 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-022 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-023 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-024 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-025 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-026 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-027 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-028 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-029 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-030 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-035 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-036 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-037 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-warn-001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-warn-002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-warn-003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-reification-required-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-uri-substructure-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xmllang-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xmllang-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xmllang-test003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xmllang-test004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xmllang-test005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xmllang-test006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfs-domain-and-range-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfs-domain-and-range-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
unrecognised-xml-attributes-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test007 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test009 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test010 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test014 [APPROVED] Test output corrected to use correct base URL. PassPassPassPassPassPassUndecided

Tests With 7 Passes (7 Approved Positive Parser Test)

Testrdflib: RDF Library for PythonRDF API for PHP V0.7RDFStore RDF/XML ParserRaptor RDF Parser3store RDF engineJena2Euler
Percent Passing (of 7 tests)100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
rdf-charmod-uris-test002 [APPROVED] A uriref which already has % escaping is permitted. No unescaping algorithm is applied. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdfms-duplicate-member-props-test001 [APPROVED] The question posed to the RDF WG was: should an RDF document containing multiple rdf:_n properties (with the same n) on an element be rejected as illegal? The WG decided that a parser should accept that case as legal RDF. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test016 [APPROVED] Like rdfms-empty-property-elements/test001.rdf but with a processing instruction as the only content of the otherwise empty element. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test017 [APPROVED] Like rdfms-empty-property-elements/test001.rdf but with a comment as the only content of the otherwise empty element. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-test001 [APPROVED] rdf:nodeID can be used to label a blank node. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-test002 [APPROVED] rdf:nodeID can be used to label a blank node. These have file scope and are distinct from any unlabelled blank nodes. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-test003 [APPROVED] On an rdf:Description or typed node rdf:nodeID behaves similarly to an rdf:about. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass

Results Grouped By Number Of Fails

Approved
Positive Parser TestNegative Parser TestPositive Entailment TestNegative Entailment TestMiscellaneous Test
Tests With 0 Fails107617161
Tests With 1 Fail1834250
Tests With 2 Fails31200

Tests With 0 Fails (107 Approved Positive Parser Test)

Testrdflib: RDF Library for PythonRDF API for PHP V0.7RDFStore RDF/XML ParserRaptor RDF Parser3store RDF engineJena2Euler
Percent Passing (of 107 tests)100%100%92%100% 9%100%82%
amp-in-url-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
datatypes-test002 [APPROVED] A parser is not required to know about well-formed datatyped literals. PassPassPassPassPassPassUndecided
rdf-charmod-uris-test002 [APPROVED] A uriref which already has % escaping is permitted. No unescaping algorithm is applied. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0009 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0010 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0011 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0012 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0013 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdf-ns-prefix-confusion-test0014 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-difference-between-ID-and-about-test1 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-duplicate-member-props-test001 [APPROVED] The question posed to the RDF WG was: should an RDF document containing multiple rdf:_n properties (with the same n) on an element be rejected as illegal? The WG decided that a parser should accept that case as legal RDF. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test007 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test008 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test009 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test010 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test011 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test012 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test013 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test014 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test015 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test016 [APPROVED] Like rdfms-empty-property-elements/test001.rdf but with a processing instruction as the only content of the otherwise empty element. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-test017 [APPROVED] Like rdfms-empty-property-elements/test001.rdf but with a comment as the only content of the otherwise empty element. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdfms-identity-anon-resources-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-identity-anon-resources-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-identity-anon-resources-test003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-identity-anon-resources-test004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-identity-anon-resources-test005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-not-id-and-resource-attr-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-para196-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-007 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-008 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-009 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-010 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-011 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-012 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-013 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-014 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-015 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-016 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-017 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-018 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-019 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-020 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-021 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-022 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-023 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-024 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-025 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-026 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-027 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-028 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-029 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-030 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-032 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-033 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-034 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-035 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-036 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-037 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-warn-001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-warn-002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-warn-003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-reification-required-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-test001 [APPROVED] rdf:nodeID can be used to label a blank node. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-test002 [APPROVED] rdf:nodeID can be used to label a blank node. These have file scope and are distinct from any unlabelled blank nodes. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-test003 [APPROVED] On an rdf:Description or typed node rdf:nodeID behaves similarly to an rdf:about. PassPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-test004 [APPROVED] On a property element rdf:nodeID behaves similarly to rdf:resource. PassPassUndecidedPassPassPassUndecided
rdfms-uri-substructure-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xmllang-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xmllang-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xmllang-test003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xmllang-test004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xmllang-test005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xmllang-test006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfs-domain-and-range-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
rdfs-domain-and-range-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
unrecognised-xml-attributes-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
unrecognised-xml-attributes-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
xmlbase-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
xmlbase-test006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassUndecided
xmlbase-test007 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test009 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test010 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassPassPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test014 [APPROVED] Test output corrected to use correct base URL. PassPassPassPassPassPassUndecided

Tests With 0 Fails (6 Approved Negative Parser Test)

Testrdflib: RDF Library for PythonRDF API for PHP V0.7RDFStore RDF/XML ParserRaptor RDF ParserJena2
Percent Passing (of 6 tests)100%100% 0%100%100%
rdfms-abouteach-error001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-error001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-error002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassPass
rdfms-empty-property-elements-error003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-011 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassUndecidedPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-error004 [APPROVED] Cannot have rdf:nodeID and rdf:ID. PassPassUndecidedPassPass

Tests With 0 Fails (17 Approved Positive Entailment Test)

Test3store RDF engineJena2EulerSurnia
Percent Passing (of 17 tests)70%82%100%47%
datatypes-intensional-xsd-integer-string-incompatible [APPROVED] The claim that xsd:integer is a subClassOF xsd:string is incompatible with using the intensional semantics for datatypes. no dataPassPassno data
datatypes-non-well-formed-literal-1 [APPROVED] Without datatype knowledge, a 'badly-formed' datatyped literal cannot be detected. PassPassPassPass
datatypes-plain-literal-and-xsd-string [APPROVED] A plain literal denotes the same thing as its corresponding xsd:string, where one exists. no dataPassPassno data
datatypes-range-clash [APPROVED] Where sufficient DT knowledge is available, a range clash may be detected; the document then contains a contradiction. PassPassPassno data
datatypes-semantic-equivalence-within-type-1 [APPROVED] Demonstrating the semantic equivalence of two lexical forms of the same datatyped value. PassPassPassno data
datatypes-semantic-equivalence-within-type-2 [APPROVED] As semantic-equivalence-within-type-1; the entailment works both ways. PassPassPassno data
datatypes-test008 [APPROVED] From decisions listed in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/w3c-rdfcore-wg/2002Oct/0098.html PassPassPassno data
datatypes-test010 [APPROVED] From decisions listed in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/w3c-rdfcore-wg/2002Oct/0098.html PassPassPassno data
pfps-10-non-well-formed-literal-1 [APPROVED] Test that ICEXT(I(rdfs:Literal)) is a subset of LV. no datano dataPassPass
rdfms-seq-representation-test003 [APPROVED] Statement of the MT closure rule. PassPassPassPass
rdfs-entailment-test001 [APPROVED] Indicating a simple inconsistency drawn from RDFS. RDFS can only produce inconsistencies through badly-formed XMLLiteral datatypes. no datano dataPassno data
rdfs-entailment-test002 [APPROVED] From an inconsistent graph, any entailment can be drawn. This is an example. no datano dataPassno data
rdfs-no-cycles-in-subClassOf-test001 [APPROVED] Cycles are permitted in subClassOf; therefore, no error occurs and the following entailment holds trivially. PassPassPassPass
rdfs-no-cycles-in-subPropertyOf-test001 [APPROVED] Cycles are permitted in subPropertyOf; therefore, no error occurs and the following entailment holds trivially. PassPassPassPass
rdfs-subPropertyOf-semantics-test001 [APPROVED] The inheritance semantics of the subPropertyOf relationship needs to be clarified. => subProperties inherit conjunctively the domain and range of their superproperties PassPassPassPass
tex-01-language-tag-case-1 [APPROVED] The case of the language tag is not significant. PassPassPassPass
tex-01-language-tag-case-2 [APPROVED] The case of the language tag is not significant. PassPassPassPass

Tests With 0 Fails (16 Approved Negative Entailment Test)

None
Test3store RDF engineJena2EulerSurnia
Percent Passing (of 16 tests)75% 0% 0%68%
datatypes-intensional-xsd-integer-decimal-compatible [APPROVED] The claim that xsd:integer is a subClassOF xsd:decimal is not incompatible with using the intensional semantics for datatypes. no dataUndecidedUndecidedno data
datatypes-non-well-formed-literal-2 [APPROVED] With appropriate datatype knowledge, a 'badly-formed' datatyped literal can be detected. PassUndecidedUndecidedno data
horst-01-subClassOf-intensional [APPROVED] rdfs:subClassOf has intensional semantics, not extensional. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
rdf-charmod-uris-test003 [APPROVED] An international URI ref and its %-escaped form label different nodes in the graph. No model theoretic relationship holds between them. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
rdf-charmod-uris-test004 [APPROVED] An international URI ref and its %-escaped form label different nodes in the graph. No model theoretic relationship holds between them. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
rdfms-xmllang-test007a [APPROVED] Plain literals are distinguishable on the basis of language tags. no dataUndecidedUndecidedno data
rdfms-xmllang-test007b [APPROVED] Plain literals are distinguishable on the basis of language tags. no dataUndecidedUndecidedno data
rdfms-xmllang-test007c [APPROVED] Plain literals are distinguishable on the basis of language tags. no dataUndecidedUndecidedno data
rdfs-container-membership-superProperty-test001 [APPROVED] While it is a superproperty, _:a <rdfs:contains (@@member?)> _:b . does NOT entail _:a <rdf:_n> _:b . for any _n. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
rdfs-domain-and-range-intensionality-domain [APPROVED] RDF Semantics defines rdfs:range to have an intensional reading of domain. However, semantic extensions may give an extensional reading to domain. The premise/conclusion pair is a non-entailment for RDFS reasoning, but may hold in semantic extensions. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
rdfs-domain-and-range-intensionality-range [APPROVED] RDF Semantics defines rdfs:range to have an intensional reading. However, semantic extensions may give an extensional reading to range. The premise/conclusion pair is a non-entailment for RDFS reasoning, but may hold in semantic extensions. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
rdfs-subClassOf-a-Property-test001 [APPROVED] an instance of the Property class may have an rdfs:subClassOf property. the meaning of such a property is defined by the model theory. The wording of the formal resolution is a bit bare, so let me add a few words of explanation. What this means is that a resource can be both a class and a property. This test is encoded as follows: a Property may have a subclass (that is, such an RDF graph is satisfiable) PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
statement-entailment-test001 [APPROVED] RDFCore WG RESOLVED that a reified statement was a stating, not a statement. The following entailment does not, therefore, hold. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
statement-entailment-test002 [APPROVED] RDFCore WG RESOLVED that a statement does NOT entail its reification. The following entailment does not, therefore, hold. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
statement-entailment-test003 [APPROVED] RDFCore WG RESOLVED that a reified statement was a stating, not a statement. The following entailment does not, therefore, hold. This is the same as test001, but using RDFS-entailment. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass
statement-entailment-test004 [APPROVED] RDFCore WG RESOLVED that a statement does NOT entail its reification. The following entailment does not, therefore, hold. This is the same as test002, but using RDFS-entailment. PassUndecidedUndecidedPass

Tests With 0 Fails (1 Approved Miscellaneous Test)

Test
Percent Passing (of 1 tests)
rdfms-uri-substructure-error001 [APPROVED] An RDF/XML serlializer is recommended to produce an exception if asked to serialize the following graph since there is no way to represent it in the RDF/XML syntax.

Tests With 1 Fail (18 Approved Positive Parser Test)

Testrdflib: RDF Library for PythonRDF API for PHP V0.7RDFStore RDF/XML ParserRaptor RDF Parser3store RDF engineJena2Euler
Percent Passing (of 18 tests)94%88%16%100%16%100%44%
datatypes-test001 [APPROVED] A simple datatype production; a language+datatype production. Simply duplicate the constructs under http://www.w3.org/2000/10/rdf-tests/rdfcore/ntriples/test.nt FailPassPassPassPassPassPass
rdf-charmod-literals-test001 [APPROVED] Does the treatment of literals conform to charmod ? Test for success of legal Normal Form C literal PassFailPassPassPassPassUndecided
rdf-charmod-uris-test001 [APPROVED] A uriref is allowed to match non-US ASCII forms conforming to Unicode Normal Form C. No escaping algorithm is applied. PassFailPassPassPassPassUndecided
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test007 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-test008 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
rdf-element-not-mandatory-test001 [APPROVED] A surrounding rdf:RDF element is no longer mandatory. PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-not-id-and-resource-attr-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-not-id-and-resource-attr-test004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-not-id-and-resource-attr-test005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-rdf-names-use-test-031 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
rdfms-xml-literal-namespaces-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
rdfms-xml-literal-namespaces-test002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided
xml-canon-test001 [APPROVED] Demonstrating the canonicalisation of XMLLiterals. PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test008 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test011 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassPass
xmlbase-test013 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassno dataPassUndecided

Tests With 1 Fail (34 Approved Negative Parser Test)

Testrdflib: RDF Library for PythonRDF API for PHP V0.7RDFStore RDF/XML ParserRaptor RDF ParserJena2
Percent Passing (of 34 tests)100%100% 0%100%100%
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-error001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdf-containers-syntax-vs-schema-error002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-abouteach-error002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error001 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:ID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error002 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:ID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error003 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:ID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error004 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:ID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error005 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:ID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error006 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:bagID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-id-error007 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:bagID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-001 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-002 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-003 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-004 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-005 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-006 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-007 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-008 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-009 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-010 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-012 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-013 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-014 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-015 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-016 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-017 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-018 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-019 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-rdf-names-use-error-020 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-error001 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:nodeID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-error002 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:nodeID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-error003 [APPROVED] The value of rdf:nodeID must match the XML Name production, (as modified by XML Namespaces). PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-error005 [APPROVED] Cannot have rdf:nodeID and rdf:about. PassPassFailPassPass
rdfms-syntax-incomplete-error006 [APPROVED] Cannot have rdf:nodeID and rdf:resource. PassPassFailPassPass

Tests With 1 Fail (2 Approved Positive Entailment Test)

Test3store RDF engineJena2Euler
Percent Passing (of 2 tests) 0%50%100%
datatypes-semantic-equivalence-between-datatypes [APPROVED] Members of different datatypes may be semantically equivalent. FailPassPass
xmlsch-02-whitespace-facet-3 [APPROVED] A simple test for well-formedness of a typed literal. Failno dataPass

Tests With 1 Fail (5 Approved Negative Entailment Test)

None
Test3store RDF engineJena2EulerSurnia
Percent Passing (of 5 tests)80% 0% 0%20%
datatypes-test009 [APPROVED] From decisions listed in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/w3c-rdfcore-wg/2002Oct/0098.html FailUndecidedUndecidedno data
horst-01-subPropertyOf-intensional [APPROVED] rdfs:subPropertyOf has intensional semantics, not extensional. PassUndecidedFailPass
xmlsch-02-whitespace-facet-1 [APPROVED] A well-formed typed literal is not related to an ill-formed literal. Even if they only differ by whitespace. PassUndecidedFailno data
xmlsch-02-whitespace-facet-2 [APPROVED] A well-formed typed literal is not related to an ill-formed literal. Even if they only differ by whitespace. PassUndecidedFailno data
xmlsch-02-whitespace-facet-4 [APPROVED] An integer with whitespace is ill-formed. PassUndecidedFailno data

Tests With 2 Fails (3 Approved Positive Parser Test)

Testrdflib: RDF Library for PythonRDF API for PHP V0.7RDFStore RDF/XML ParserRaptor RDF Parser3store RDF engineJena2Euler
Percent Passing (of 3 tests)66%33% 0%100%66%100%33%
rdfms-difference-between-ID-and-about-test2 [APPROVED] This test shows the treatment of non-ASCII characters in the value of rdf:ID attribute. PassFailFailPassPassPassUndecided
rdfms-difference-between-ID-and-about-test3 [APPROVED] This test shows the treatment of non-ASCII characters in the value of rdf:about attribute. PassFailFailPassPassPassUndecided
rdfms-seq-representation-test001 [APPROVED] (no description given)FailPassFailPassno dataPassPass

Tests With 2 Fails (1 Approved Negative Parser Test)

Testrdflib: RDF Library for PythonRDF API for PHP V0.7RDFStore RDF/XML ParserRaptor RDF ParserJena2
Percent Passing (of 1 tests)100% 0% 0%100%100%
rdfms-difference-between-ID-and-about-error1 [APPROVED] (no description given)PassFailFailPassPass

Tests With 2 Fails (2 Approved Positive Entailment Test)

Test3store RDF engineJena2EulerSurnia
Percent Passing (of 2 tests) 0% 0%100%100%
rdfms-seq-representation-test002 [APPROVED] Statement of the MT closure rule. FailFailPassPass
rdfms-seq-representation-test004 [APPROVED] Statement of the MT closure rule. FailFailPassPass