w3c/wbs-design or
by mail to sysreq.
W3C
Site Navigation
Nearby
Results of Questionnaire 26 Apr HTML WG Teleconference
The results of this questionnaire are available to anybody.
This questionnaire was open from 2007-04-18 to 2007-04-26.
84 answers have been received.
Jump to results for question:
1. Logistics and Agenda
It seems we have enough agenda topics and issues to merit a teleconference.
Dan and Chris invite you to meet Thu, 26 April at 1700 UTC (1pm Boston, 10am Los Angeles, and yes, 2am Friday in Tokyo; sorry).
Dan will send a detailed agenda with exact time, phone number, etc. at least 24 hours before the meeting.
The teleconference will be recorded in IRC in near-real-time, and we'll make an effort to accommodate IRC-only participation. Edited minutes will go out by email within a day or two.
If you have any input to the agenda, you're welcome to give it here or by email to the WG.
Details
| Responder | Logistics and Agenda |
|---|---|
| Benjamin Chait | |
| David Håsäther | |
| Dan Connolly | |
| Magnus Kristiansen | |
| Carol King | |
| M. Jackson Wilkinson | |
| Danny Liang | |
| Simon Pieters | |
| Olivier Gendrin | |
| Brad Fults | |
| Andrew Neitsch | |
| Arthur Jennings | |
| Sean Fraser | |
| Sander Tekelenburg | |
| Leonard Chin | |
| Chasen Le Hara | |
| Laurens Holst | If it were 1 or two hours earlier, they would still be realistic times in LA (10am or 9am) while being a little easier on the people in Japan. That time will probably also better suit Europeans living on the mainland, as 18:00 will be out of office hours for most people, so 17:00 or 16:00 would be better. |
| Pasquale Popolizio | |
| Diego La Monica | |
| Clair Dunn | |
| Jens Bannmann | |
| Josef Spillner | Clarification would be needed on the top200 vs. top200-US sites survey suggestions. The latter one would clearly produce skewed results, but the former one should also not be more than a tiny source of input, as top sites usually don't build HTML pages, they buy them instead. |
| Arne Johannessen | |
| James Cassell | |
| Mihai Sucan | |
| Nicolas Le Gall | 7pm in Paris. |
| Guillaume Guérin | |
| Bob Hopgood | |
| Murray Maloney | |
| Craig Saila | |
| Alfonso Martínez de Lizarrondo | |
| Sierk Bornemann | I would be glad, if we use this HTML WG to discuss and maybe to offer a new solution/new HTML elements/new mechanism to provide the user of a webpage the possibility to publish email adresses on his webpage (like it is demanded in some countries to fulfill the law concerning imprints and contact addresses) *without* the danger to be harvested by spam bots. The address prefix 'mailto:' inclusive a email address in plaintext is an invitation to any mail/spam bot. That's because some ugly, quirky solutions via JavaScript/PHP/Gifs/Captchas have spread the web, but none of it is a proper and reasonable solution for the average user this Working group mainly addresses. I think of a new mechanism, easy to handle for everyone except for bots. Maybe with the possibility of a digital signature like PGP or XML-Signature (http://www.w3.org/TR/xmldsig-core/) I vaguely think of a solution, like it is implemented in FOAF, where email addresses could be encrypted and published via SHA1, see http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/#term_mbox_sha1sum, to gain this goal. |
| Benjamin Hedrington | |
| Benjamin Meadowcroft | |
| Tyler Roehmholdt | |
| Jeff Schiller | Shouldn't 1700UTC be 2pm Boston and 1pm Chicago ? |
| Matthew Ratzloff | |
| Debi Orton | |
| Zdenko Vujasinovic | |
| Sandy Smith | |
| Stefan More | |
| Nick Drago | |
| Henrik Dvergsdal | |
| Nicholas Branigan | |
| Julian Reschke | |
| Daniel Glazman | |
| David Dailey | |
| David Savage | |
| Gregory Rosmaita | |
| Doug Schepers | |
| David Baron | 1700UTC is 10am in Los Angeles |
| Kevin Yank | |
| Ryan Cook | |
| S Emerson | |
| Terje Bless | |
| Preston Bannister | |
| Henri Sivonen | I have doubts about the usefulness of a teleconference. I see the decision on spec starting point and editor as prerequisites for other work and it seems to me that a telecon can't be used to decide on the spec starting point and the editor due to necessarily limited participation. |
| Stephen Stewart | |
| Michael[tm] Smith | |
| Chris Wilson | |
| David Hyatt | |
| John S. Thomsen | |
| Robert Brodrecht | |
| Alejandro Fernandez | |
| Matthew Otto | |
| Patrick D F Ion | |
| Gavin Sharp | |
| Doug Wright | |
| Ian Hickson | http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-html/2007JanMar/0578.html http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-html/2007Apr/1174.html |
| James Graham | |
| Sander van Lambalgen | |
| Craig Cadwallader | |
| Lachlan Hunt | |
| Maciej Stachowiak | |
| Erik van Kempen | |
| Bill Mason | |
| John-Mark Bell | |
| Anne van Kesteren | |
| Matthew Raymond | |
| Lars Erik Bolstad | |
| Tim McMahon | |
| Laura Carlson | |
| Elliott Sprehn | |
| Bhasker V Kode |
2. Are you interested and available to meet?
We'd like to know how many participants to plan for. If you plan to attend, answer yes. To offer regrets, answer no.
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| yes | 48 |
| no | 36 |
Details
| Responder | Are you interested and available to meet? | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| Benjamin Chait | no | unavailable |
| David Håsäther | no | |
| Dan Connolly | yes | |
| Magnus Kristiansen | yes | |
| Carol King | yes | |
| M. Jackson Wilkinson | yes | |
| Danny Liang | no | |
| Simon Pieters | no | If I do attend, it will be on IRC. |
| Olivier Gendrin | no | |
| Brad Fults | no | Possibly over IRC. |
| Andrew Neitsch | no | |
| Arthur Jennings | no | |
| Sean Fraser | no | Unavailable. I will be interested in reading comments re: Chris W's "survey the top 200 web sites regularly." |
| Sander Tekelenburg | no | |
| Leonard Chin | no | 2am Friday is a tough ask! |
| Chasen Le Hara | yes | It's going to be at 11 am my time, so I can join for about thirty minutes or so. Is this acceptable, or should any person planning to meet be there for the entire session? |
| Laurens Holst | yes | |
| Pasquale Popolizio | yes | I'll connect by IRC. |
| Diego La Monica | no | I'm agree, I think it is necessary but I'm surelly unavailable! Maybe for some time i could partecipate via IRC |
| Clair Dunn | yes | |
| Jens Bannmann | no | Interested in IRC participation, but unavailable on Thursdays |
| Josef Spillner | yes | I plan to participate on IRC. |
| Arne Johannessen | no | |
| James Cassell | no | |
| Mihai Sucan | yes | Yes, I am interested, and I intend to participate - only on IRC. |
| Nicolas Le Gall | yes | |
| Guillaume Guérin | yes | |
| Bob Hopgood | no | With the number of people involved I do not anticipate it having much value. |
| Murray Maloney | yes | I will try to be on the call. I may be late. |
| Craig Saila | yes | |
| Alfonso Martínez de Lizarrondo | no | |
| Sierk Bornemann | yes | If it is possible to share the teleconference via Skype, I would try to use Skype (I never have used it before and need a short assistance to adjust it right to this conferences' needs). Otherwise, I will stick to participate via IRC. |
| Benjamin Hedrington | yes | |
| Benjamin Meadowcroft | yes | |
| Tyler Roehmholdt | yes | I'll most likely be able to participate via IRC but I'll be working to get in on the phone call as well. |
| Jeff Schiller | no | Wish I could attend, but it interferes with my day job. |
| Matthew Ratzloff | yes | |
| Debi Orton | yes | |
| Zdenko Vujasinovic | yes | |
| Sandy Smith | yes | |
| Stefan More | no | |
| Nick Drago | no | unavailable |
| Henrik Dvergsdal | yes | |
| Nicholas Branigan | no | I plan on following along on IRC |
| Julian Reschke | yes | |
| Daniel Glazman | yes | |
| David Dailey | yes | May have to leave early -- 2:00 pm obligation. |
| David Savage | no | I will review the minutes once they are available. |
| Gregory Rosmaita | yes | |
| Doug Schepers | yes | |
| David Baron | yes | I can attend, but I'm not sure that a teleconference will be useful. |
| Kevin Yank | no | |
| Ryan Cook | no | |
| S Emerson | yes | IRC if available. Can only stay for 1 hour. |
| Terje Bless | yes | |
| Preston Bannister | no | |
| Henri Sivonen | yes | If the telecon takes place, I'll dial in. |
| Stephen Stewart | no | |
| Michael[tm] Smith | yes | |
| Chris Wilson | yes | |
| David Hyatt | yes | http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-html/2007Apr/1358.html |
| John S. Thomsen | no | |
| Robert Brodrecht | yes | Definitely for IRC. Maybe for phone. |
| Alejandro Fernandez | no | |
| Matthew Otto | yes | |
| Patrick D F Ion | yes | |
| Gavin Sharp | yes | |
| Doug Wright | no | Probably IRC. |
| Ian Hickson | yes | I shall try to attend the teleconference. |
| James Graham | yes | I can attend via IRC only |
| Sander van Lambalgen | no | Will try my best to be in IRC, but the time is difficult. |
| Craig Cadwallader | no | Have conflict but would follow if possible via IRC transcript |
| Lachlan Hunt | yes | |
| Maciej Stachowiak | yes | |
| Erik van Kempen | no | |
| Bill Mason | no | Unfortunately, I have a last-minute other commitment. |
| John-Mark Bell | no | I will, however, be on IRC. |
| Anne van Kesteren | yes | It seems like I can attend after all. |
| Matthew Raymond | yes | |
| Lars Erik Bolstad | yes | I plan to participate via IRC. |
| Tim McMahon | yes | |
| Laura Carlson | no | Unfortunately, I have a last-minute other commitment. |
| Elliott Sprehn | yes | Possibly having a meeting at the same time, would still like to attend though. |
| Bhasker V Kode | no |
3. Supplemental Orientation Discussion
summary | by responder | by choice
In addition to the technical scope of this HTML WG, I can imagine there are lots of things people might naturally start discussing once we get together by phone... everything from W3C patent policy to collaboration tools.
In order to optimize the official WG teleconference time, I'm considering a supplemental orientation discussion, either before or after the main teleconference, or perhaps at a different time altogether.
What would you like to learn about? What would you like to say to your fellow WG participants? Use the comment field to say, and check all the options that apply.
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| I have experience with W3C tools and process, and I'm interested and available to help orient others. | 4 |
| I'm new to W3C and interested in spending some time on the phone getting oriented. | 20 |
| I'd like the orientation to be just before the main teleconference. | 23 |
| I'd like the orientation to be just after the main teleconference. | 7 |
| I'd like the orientation to be at a different time from the main teleconference altogether. (Please specify in a comment.) | 4 |
Skip to view by choice.
View by responder
Details
| Responder | Supplemental Orientation Discussion | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| Benjamin Chait | ||
| David Håsäther | ||
| Dan Connolly |
|
|
| Magnus Kristiansen |
|
|
| Carol King | ||
| M. Jackson Wilkinson |
|
|
| Danny Liang | ||
| Simon Pieters | ||
| Olivier Gendrin | ||
| Brad Fults | ||
| Andrew Neitsch | ||
| Arthur Jennings | ||
| Sean Fraser | ||
| Sander Tekelenburg | ||
| Leonard Chin | ||
| Chasen Le Hara |
|
I personally would prefer the orientation to be the day before at the same time, or perhaps a couple hours later; of course, I have no objects to it being at a time that doesn't fit my schedule (how selfish would that be!). |
| Laurens Holst |
|
|
| Pasquale Popolizio |
|
|
| Diego La Monica | ||
| Clair Dunn |
|
I'm willing to arrange my schedule to participate anytime. Thank you. |
| Jens Bannmann | ||
| Josef Spillner |
|
It seems that to quite a few people it isn't exactly clear how this WG's work will influence the XHTML2 work and vice-versa, and similarly how to involve the CSS people. This should be added to the supplemental agenda. |
| Arne Johannessen | ||
| James Cassell | ||
| Mihai Sucan |
|
|
| Nicolas Le Gall |
|
|
| Guillaume Guérin |
|
|
| Bob Hopgood | I would like to see a more structured discussion with issues raised, pros and cons established in a reasonably formal manner and then some mechanism to move forward with a resolution. The current tidal wave of comments backwards and forwards appear to make little progress, is unfocused, and contains many comments that are treated as correct just because nobody bothers to refute them. | |
| Murray Maloney | I guess that I will have to learn how to use tools. Should I plan a trip to Boston -- I would have to drive there -- to learn how to use all of the editing and repository tools? | |
| Craig Saila |
|
|
| Alfonso Martínez de Lizarrondo |
|
|
| Sierk Bornemann |
|
|
| Benjamin Hedrington |
|
|
| Benjamin Meadowcroft |
|
|
| Tyler Roehmholdt |
|
|
| Jeff Schiller | ||
| Matthew Ratzloff |
|
|
| Debi Orton |
|
I am a complete newbie to the W3C workgroup process and am feeling more than a little lost. |
| Zdenko Vujasinovic |
|
|
| Sandy Smith |
|
|
| Stefan More |
|
|
| Nick Drago | ||
| Henrik Dvergsdal |
|
|
| Nicholas Branigan | ||
| Julian Reschke |
|
|
| Daniel Glazman | ||
| David Dailey |
|
|
| David Savage | ||
| Gregory Rosmaita |
|
|
| Doug Schepers | ||
| David Baron | ||
| Kevin Yank |
|
|
| Ryan Cook |
|
|
| S Emerson |
|
|
| Terje Bless | ||
| Preston Bannister | ||
| Henri Sivonen |
|
I may not be aware of all W3C collaboration tools. |
| Stephen Stewart | ||
| Michael[tm] Smith |
|
|
| Chris Wilson | ||
| David Hyatt | ||
| John S. Thomsen | ||
| Robert Brodrecht | ||
| Alejandro Fernandez | ||
| Matthew Otto |
|
|
| Patrick D F Ion |
|
|
| Gavin Sharp |
|
|
| Doug Wright | ||
| Ian Hickson | ||
| James Graham | ||
| Sander van Lambalgen | ||
| Craig Cadwallader | ||
| Lachlan Hunt |
|
|
| Maciej Stachowiak | ||
| Erik van Kempen | ||
| Bill Mason | ||
| John-Mark Bell | ||
| Anne van Kesteren | ||
| Matthew Raymond | ||
| Lars Erik Bolstad | ||
| Tim McMahon | ||
| Laura Carlson | ||
| Elliott Sprehn |
|
|
| Bhasker V Kode |
|
orientation ,perhaps the same time next week ?Also, if there is a wiki template similiar to the whatwg that shows hwo newcomers can contribute in written work .that would be great. |
View by choice
| Choice | Responders |
|---|---|
| I have experience with W3C tools and process, and I'm interested and available to help orient others. |
|
| I'm new to W3C and interested in spending some time on the phone getting oriented. |
|
| I'd like the orientation to be just before the main teleconference. |
|
| I'd like the orientation to be just after the main teleconference. |
|
| I'd like the orientation to be at a different time from the main teleconference altogether. (Please specify in a comment.) |
|
More details on responses
- Benjamin Chait: last responded on 18, April 2007 at 22:32 (UTC)
- David Håsäther: last responded on 18, April 2007 at 22:38 (UTC)
- Dan Connolly: last responded on 18, April 2007 at 22:51 (UTC)
- Magnus Kristiansen: last responded on 18, April 2007 at 23:03 (UTC)
- Carol King: last responded on 18, April 2007 at 23:04 (UTC)
- M. Jackson Wilkinson: last responded on 18, April 2007 at 23:06 (UTC)
- Danny Liang: last responded on 18, April 2007 at 23:15 (UTC)
- Simon Pieters: last responded on 18, April 2007 at 23:21 (UTC)
- Olivier Gendrin: last responded on 18, April 2007 at 23:48 (UTC)
- Brad Fults: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 00:44 (UTC)
- Andrew Neitsch: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 00:56 (UTC)
- Arthur Jennings: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 01:03 (UTC)
- Sean Fraser: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 01:16 (UTC)
- Sander Tekelenburg: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 02:24 (UTC)
- Leonard Chin: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 04:22 (UTC)
- Chasen Le Hara: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 05:26 (UTC)
- Laurens Holst: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 05:39 (UTC)
- Pasquale Popolizio: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 05:48 (UTC)
- Diego La Monica: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 06:12 (UTC)
- Clair Dunn: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 06:15 (UTC)
- Jens Bannmann: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 06:23 (UTC)
- Josef Spillner: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 06:40 (UTC)
- Arne Johannessen: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 06:52 (UTC)
- James Cassell: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 06:57 (UTC)
- Mihai Sucan: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 09:23 (UTC)
- Nicolas Le Gall: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 09:37 (UTC)
- Guillaume Guérin: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 12:12 (UTC)
- Bob Hopgood: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 12:51 (UTC)
- Murray Maloney: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 13:16 (UTC)
- Craig Saila: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 13:25 (UTC)
- Alfonso Martínez de Lizarrondo: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 13:47 (UTC)
- Sierk Bornemann: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 15:33 (UTC)
- Benjamin Hedrington: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 16:39 (UTC)
- Benjamin Meadowcroft: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 16:57 (UTC)
- Tyler Roehmholdt: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 18:08 (UTC)
- Jeff Schiller: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 18:19 (UTC)
- Matthew Ratzloff: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 20:10 (UTC)
- Debi Orton: last responded on 19, April 2007 at 20:46 (UTC)
- Zdenko Vujasinovic: last responded on 20, April 2007 at 09:35 (UTC)
- Sandy Smith: last responded on 20, April 2007 at 14:45 (UTC)
- Stefan More: last responded on 21, April 2007 at 20:49 (UTC)
- Nick Drago: last responded on 22, April 2007 at 02:32 (UTC)
- Henrik Dvergsdal: last responded on 22, April 2007 at 07:38 (UTC)
- Nicholas Branigan: last responded on 22, April 2007 at 19:01 (UTC)
- Julian Reschke: last responded on 23, April 2007 at 10:09 (UTC)
- Daniel Glazman: last responded on 23, April 2007 at 11:42 (UTC)
- David Dailey: last responded on 23, April 2007 at 14:51 (UTC)
- David Savage: last responded on 23, April 2007 at 20:37 (UTC)
- Gregory Rosmaita: last responded on 23, April 2007 at 20:45 (UTC)
- Doug Schepers: last responded on 23, April 2007 at 21:41 (UTC)
- David Baron: last responded on 24, April 2007 at 02:42 (UTC)
- Kevin Yank: last responded on 24, April 2007 at 03:13 (UTC)
- Ryan Cook: last responded on 24, April 2007 at 03:48 (UTC)
- S Emerson: last responded on 24, April 2007 at 04:19 (UTC)
- Terje Bless: last responded on 24, April 2007 at 05:07 (UTC)
- Preston Bannister: last responded on 24, April 2007 at 06:37 (UTC)
- Henri Sivonen: last responded on 24, April 2007 at 06:45 (UTC)
- Stephen Stewart: last responded on 24, April 2007 at 08:15 (UTC)
- Michael[tm] Smith: last responded on 24, April 2007 at 08:21 (UTC)
- Chris Wilson: last responded on 24, April 2007 at 14:16 (UTC)
- David Hyatt: last responded on 24, April 2007 at 14:17 (UTC)
- John S. Thomsen: last responded on 24, April 2007 at 18:42 (UTC)
- Robert Brodrecht: last responded on 25, April 2007 at 01:23 (UTC)
- Alejandro Fernandez: last responded on 25, April 2007 at 09:49 (UTC)
- Matthew Otto: last responded on 25, April 2007 at 11:04 (UTC)
- Patrick D F Ion: last responded on 25, April 2007 at 14:58 (UTC)
- Gavin Sharp: last responded on 25, April 2007 at 18:03 (UTC)
- Doug Wright: last responded on 25, April 2007 at 18:23 (UTC)
- Ian Hickson: last responded on 25, April 2007 at 18:37 (UTC)
- James Graham: last responded on 25, April 2007 at 20:41 (UTC)
- Sander van Lambalgen: last responded on 25, April 2007 at 21:34 (UTC)
- Craig Cadwallader: last responded on 26, April 2007 at 04:44 (UTC)
- Lachlan Hunt: last responded on 26, April 2007 at 06:24 (UTC)
- Maciej Stachowiak: last responded on 26, April 2007 at 06:37 (UTC)
- Erik van Kempen: last responded on 26, April 2007 at 06:49 (UTC)
- Bill Mason: last responded on 26, April 2007 at 07:35 (UTC)
- John-Mark Bell: last responded on 26, April 2007 at 09:16 (UTC)
- Anne van Kesteren: last responded on 26, April 2007 at 12:21 (UTC)
- Matthew Raymond: last responded on 26, April 2007 at 12:24 (UTC)
- Lars Erik Bolstad: last responded on 26, April 2007 at 13:26 (UTC)
- Tim McMahon: last responded on 26, April 2007 at 14:03 (UTC)
- Laura Carlson: last responded on 26, April 2007 at 16:06 (UTC)
- Elliott Sprehn: last responded on 26, April 2007 at 16:59 (UTC)
- Bhasker V Kode: last responded on 27, April 2007 at 04:59 (UTC)
Everybody has responded to this questionnaire.
Compact view of the results / list of email addresses of the responders
WBS home / Questionnaires / WG questionnaires / Answer this questionnaire
Report issues
on GitHub project